Hoover wanted men who could handle a teacup as well as a tommy-gun. (Reading Laboratory, 3b, Book 1, p. 75)
[原译]胡佛需要既懂社交应酬又会使用手提机关枪的人。(教参)
上面的译文是否译出了 as well as 的真正含义?
大家知道,在 not only A but also B 这个结构里,语意侧重点在 B 项。但在 A as well as B 这个结构里,语意侧重点则常常在 A 项,因此 as well as 的词义在许多情况下并不简单地等同于 and,而是相当于 in addition to, not only,也就是说,作者往往把 A 看作是读者所未知的新信息,有意识地在语意上加以强调。因此,英译汉时要设法把作为句子语意重点的 A 项给强调出来,一般可以译作“不仅 B,而且 A”或“既 B 又 A”“A 和 B 一样也……”“除 B 之外,还 A”。请看下面的例句及其译法:
-
Notice that a force has direction as well as magnitude. (=... has not only magnitude but also direction.) 要注意, 力不但有大小, 而且有方向。
-
Electric energy can be changed into light energy as well as into sound energy. 电能既可以变为声能, 又可以变为光能。
-
It must be remembered that there are advantages as well as disadvantages of friction. 必须记住,摩擦力有消极作用,也有积极作用。
-
To them, I suppose I did look like a fool, but your life is shaped by the opportunities you turn down as well as by those you seize. (B. Clinton, My Life) 在他们看来, 我想我肯定像个傻瓜, 但是一个人的生活不仅仅是由你抓住的机会造成的, 而且还是由你放弃的机会造成的。(《我的生活》)
我们的上述理解和翻译是符合 R. Quirk 等人的论述的:“当用 like 和 as well as 代替 and 来连接短语时,其结果通常使它们后面的短语降格,表示该短语已处于“已知信息”的地位。” (CGEL, § 19.60)
但是,应当指出,在现代英语里,A as well as B 这个结构并不是在任何情况下都是用来在语意上突出 A 的,有时候用来表示 A 和 B 同等重要。在这种情况下,as well as 相当于 and 或 and also.例如:
- Electronic computers can add and subtract as well as multiply and divide.
电子计算机能够加减,也能乘除。
-
In recent years scientific and technological developments have changed human life on our planet, as well as our views both of ourselves as individuals in society and of the universe as a whole. (PSSC, Physics) 近几年来,科学技术上的新成就,改变了人类在地球上的生活,也改变了我们对于社会中的个人以及整个宇宙的看法。
-
I learned more about the prevalence and impact of breast cancer, as well as obstacles to its prevention and treatment. (Hillary, Living History) 对乳癌的普遍性和影响以及预防和治疗上的障碍,我有了更多的了解。
-
Premier Zhu Rongji hosted a lunch for the delegation in which we discussed the economic and social challenges facing China, as well as the remaining issues we still had to resolve in order to bring China into the World Trade Organization. (B. Clinton, My Life) 朱镕基总理为代表团设午宴,我们一起讨论了中国面临的经济和社会挑战,以及那些为了让中国加入世界贸易组织而仍需解决的问题。(《我的生活》)
由此可见,A as well as B 这个结构究竟是在语意上强调 A,还是表示 A 和 B 同等重要,这是需要对句意和上下文进行具体分析之后,才能确定的。正是根据这样的分析,我们认为,你所提问的句子中的 A as well as B 是强调 A 的,亦即强调“could handle a teacup”(懂社交应酬)。因为联邦调查局的特务会使用自动步枪是不言而喻的,但是要求他们懂社交应酬却是一种出人意料之外的新奇的想法。
[试译]胡佛需要既会使用自动步枪又懂社交礼仪的人。