词典词条 · 问答

less of

核心问题 1

It is not in the American interest to have conditions of extreme tension, even less of war, between the Soviet Union and China...

less people ^{*}

[原译]中苏之间极为紧张的局势对美国不利,发生战争则更不利……

请问 less of war 是指发生战争吗?

词典解答 1

less of = short of,因此 less of war 应为“不发生战争”。类例:

Parking is less of a problem with a small car. (The Oxford Duden German Dictionary) 对于小汽车来说, 停车场地不会有什么问题。

[试译]中苏之间的极为紧张的局势,即使不发生战争,也不符合美国的利益。

核心问题 2

(1)The industrial trend trendA\frac{\text{trend}}{\text{A}} is inB\frac{\text{in}}{\text{B}} the direction of more machines and less people. (全国研考)

(2) Because there were lessA\frac{\text{less}}{\text{A}} members present tonight thanBthereC\frac{\text{than}}{\text{B}} \frac{\text{there}}{\text{C}} were last night, we must wait until the next voting.D\frac{\text{voting.}}{\text{D}} (全国研考)

上述试题要求将 less 改为 fewer。但我认为 less people (members) 的说法是符合惯用法的。不知您手头有无这方面的证据。

词典解答 2

出题者的意图是: fewer 用在可数复数名词之前, 而 less 仅用于不可数名词之前。但是, 惯用法并不像上面所描述的那样简单, 而呈现出错综复杂的局面。正像 R. Ourk 等在 A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language 中所指的, “There is a tendency to use less (instead of fewer) and least (instead of fewest) also with count nouns. (有一种倾向, 将 less (而不用 fewer)least (而不用 fewest) 与可数名词连用):

You've made less mistakes than last time."

R. Quirk 等人虽然指出,上述用法受到一些人的指责,但并没有把上面的句子判为错句。接着他们举了一个被人们普遍接受的例子:

No less than fifty people were killed in the accident. (CGEL, p. 263) 这次事故中死者多达50人。

R. Quirk 等人在 CGEL (§ 6.53) 中还进一步指出,“传统的规定语法反对把 lessleast 与复数名词连用。然而,它们在非正式英语中,却用得十分广泛。”(p. 385),SwanPEU 中也曾明确地指出:“从理论上讲,fewer 用在复数名词之前,而 less 用于不可数名词之前。但是在现代英语中,特别是在非正式语体中,许多人在复数名词之前也用 less,而不用 fewer。”

The Right Word at the Right Time 的作者们也说:有时 fewer 在复数名词前的“正确”用法比“不正确的”less 显得更加笨拙。请看下面的例句:

We want a few more buses and a few less cars. 我们想增加几辆公共汽车,而减少几辆轿车。

下面是我们查到的例句:

  1. There used to be more women than men in the country, but now there are {fewer.less.\left\{\begin{aligned}&fewer.\\ &less.\end{aligned}\right. (CGEL) 以前这个国家女人比男人多,而现在女人比男人少了。

  2. I've got less friends this year than ever before. (PEU) 今年我的朋友比往年少。

  3. If only there were less holes in the roof! (LDCE) 要是屋顶上的洞少一些,该多好!

不难看出,上面的考题不仅无助于提高学生的英语水平,而且还会干扰他们去掌握活生生的英语实际。

据此,我们有理由提出,在今后的英语考试中不宜再把 less people 这种被语言学家们宣布为一种惯用法倾向的格式简单地判为错误。在英语考试中可以回避此类考题。

来源:英语常见问题解答大词典-5.md · 第 21642213 行 · 原文哈希 e186c3cc2c