我发现许多英语试题将 consider...as 判为错误。但在阅读中不时会遇到 consider...as 的用法,如何解释这种现象?
有的语法学家把 consider...as 斥为典型错误。例如,F. Crews 教授就曾说过:“When consider means regard, it shouldn't be followed by as: He considered me(as) his friend. The error is common because regard does take as.” (The Random House Handbook, New York, 1974, p.229) 许多国外考题持有这样的观点,例如日本浜松医大的英语试题就将“We consider him as the best candidate.”判为错句(《英语基本300题》,东京,p.75),但是这种用法,在英语文学作品、科技作品中俯拾即是。在 TOEFL 的试题中也不乏这种用法,例如:
Science and the humanities can not be considered as rivals in education, but rather as friends working together toward the same objectives. (TOEFL)
consider...as 这个格式也得到了语言学家们的普遍承认。
-
They considered it beautiful. (GCE, p. 852)
-
He was considered as a kind of god by the natives. (Practical English Usage, p. 155)
R. Quirk 等人明确指出,如同 regard as, class as 一样,consider as 代表的是另一类介词动词,即后面跟的是介词宾语补足语,而不是介词宾语:
We considered him
他们还进一步指出,下列各句中的任何一句我们都可以说或写:
I consider her my friend. ~ I consider her as my friend. (CGEL, § 1.39)
consider...x/to be x
I consider it a great honour to be here with you today.
我认为这个句子里的 consider it a great honour 应改为 consider it to be a great honour。我有托福题为证:
In the Middle Ages, the shape of a man's teeth was considered to be an indication of its character.
(将 its 改为 his)(TOEFL)
我认为 consider it a great honour 同样是正确的。我也有托福题为证:
"How about John?" "My uncle ____ a good student."
A. thinks John B. suggests John C. considers John D. knows John (TOEFL)
应当牢记,consider + 宾语(0) + 宾语补足语(C)有三种正确的结构:
We considered him