词典词条 · 问答

but ⁸

2. Take the next turning but one on your left. (ALD) 请在你左方的第二个转弯处转弯。

说明
  1. Take the next turning but one on your left. (ALD) 请在你左方的第二个转弯处转弯。

but do/but doing

核心问题

下面是《大学英语·精读》第一册的课后练习题:

With language, we can do all the following but ____

A. producing good health. B. communicating to other people.

C. passing ideas from group to group. D. turning experiences into symbols.

下面是《大学英语》1997年第8期(p.7)对上面的试题提出的否定意见:

“此题 but 后的四个选择项全部用了动名词短语;这可能是因为编者认为只要是介词,其后的动词就要用其动名词形式。殊不知,偏偏有个例外:

Prepositions can also be followed by verbs but, except after but and except, the verb must be in the gerund form;

The only exceptions to the gerund rule are except and but (preposition), which take the bare infinitive.

这就是说介词中只有 exceptbut 后接的是没有 to 的动词不定式, 而不是像其它介词那样接动名词。

I've done everything you wanted except (or but) make the beds.

所以,上列四个选择的动名词都须改为没有 to 的不定式。”

我的问题是: but 之后绝不可接动名词, 而只能接不带 to 的动词不定式吗?

词典解答

由于 but 究竟是连词还是介词,常常难以断定,所以其后既可以接动词不定式,也可以接动名词。CGEL 书中的例句可以证明这一点:

He does everything in the house {exceptbut}{putputting}\left\{ \begin{array}{l} \text{except} \\ \text{but} \end{array} \right\} \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \text{put} \\ \text{putting} \end{array} \right\} the children to bed. (CGEL, § 9.58)

除了安排孩子们上床睡觉之外,他在家里什么事都干。

[附注]but接动名词的结构用得较少。

来源:英语常见问题解答大词典-2.md · 第 58315868 行 · 原文哈希 93ce501718